Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Culturally Responsive Teaching Rough Draft

Based on what I have experienced from life and from reading “As Soon as She Opened Her Mouth” there are people who use a cultural capital approach and others that use a cultural deficit approach when interacting with others.  Typically people who are of higher power such as government, political leadership, doctors, or just wealthy tend to use cultural capital.  One thing I have learned about the relationship between language, literacy, and power is that they are all interrelated.  A way a person speaks, their discourse communities, and their status all reflect and bounce off each other.
            It’s important for educators of the Appalachian region to understand the relationship that Appalachians have to their homeland because it’s a big part of who they are.  It’s important that teachers reframe from making students feel ashamed of their culture.  In the article, the author states “Again and again we conclude that in developed countries and in third-world countries, learners from impoverished and low-status groups fail to develop as fully and productively literate as compared to learners from sociocultural groups that hold sociopolitical power and favor.” That makes no sense to me at all.
            There are multiple ways that teachers can overcome cultural deficits perspectives of their students. For example, in the Luis Moll research study teachers were asked to abandon their drill-based approach to teaching bilingual students English and to tap into their students interests and find meaningful activities that students could do that pertained to their interests.  One success story from Hilda Angiulo, was that she found out that Construction was part of their discourse community, so she based lessons off of building models, researching vocabulary, and have Construction workers from the community to come in and explain their stories of how construction workers work with numbers, measurements, and problem solve everyday.  “When teachers and schools seek out and use these funds of knowledge, Moll expects there will be rewards: They will have a better chance of helping bilingual and minority children achieve authentic literacy; they will foster a sense of community; and they will bestow a much richer education than most working-class kids enjoy.”
            To be continued…..

3 comments:

  1. I think you did a really good job of explaining strategies for overcoming cultual deficit perspectives. Refrencing Moll's suggestion to abandon drill-based learning in favor of teaching methods that would tap into students' interests and to make learning more meaningful and personal for them hit the nail right on the head!
    One thing you might want to look at is the part in the first paragraph when you write
    "Typically people who are of higher power such as government, political leadership, doctors, or just wealthy tend to use cultural capital."
    I think cultural capitol means viewing a person's cultural characteristics as valuable assets. Im not sure that it is necessarily associated with people in power.
    I thought I would just point that out to you... but your reflection is well written, and you used the quotes well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Katie,
    This is a decent start, but I was expecting your reflection to be much longer. I also agree with Kitty in that your use of the term cultural capital is incorrect. I like that you were able to use your own experience as a point of reference which in turn made your writing more relatable. Good start.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you both for your feedback. Sorry it wasn't completely finished yet, I had a lot of stuff going on this weekend and hardly had time to sit down and write. But thank you both for letting me know about the usage of cultural Capitol, I will change my wording around to fit it better with the meaning.

      Delete